Okay. I'm going to say something a little schematic about French cinema. But if we imagine two lines, we can say there is [Jean] Renoir and [Robert] Bresson that gave us [Francois] Truffaut and [Jean-Luc] Godard, that gave us [Maurice] Pialat and [Jean] Eustache, that gave us [Arnaud] Desplechin and [Leos] Carax. I fall more on the Bresson/Godard/Eustache/Carax side than the other one - Bertrand Bonello,
cineaste.com That quote above is an important passage to remember before going in to Bertrand Bonello’s latest sci-fi tale because there are a lot of Leos Carax-isms throughout (beautiful-looking comedic absurdity masked underneath a layer of arthouse cinema).
The Beast comes off like a cross between
Holy Motors and
Highlander with a pinch of Maya Deren’s
Meshes Of The Afternoon told from the perspective of an incel. I can namedrop folks like Deren & Carax without giving any background because chances are anyone looking forward to
The Beast will already be familiar with Bonello's work and his influences. This is not the kind of movie that you just blindly watch. Now...I know my description of this movie sounds like a fun little “gumbo” of influences & ideas, but at the end of the day it doesn’t work. That’s what’s so frustrating. To have so much in common with so many fun cinematic reference-points to be a big nothing almost takes extra effort to accomplish. I’m a Bertrand Bonello fan/occasional defender but I can’t defend this one.
The Beast is very much a mixture of all the things I just mentioned but it’s kind of a mess as opposed to a well-crafted collage of ideas. I really don’t know who this was made for outside of bored disingenuous letterboxed "critics" that love to go against the grain and claim that bad movies are
really misunderstood masterpieces.
The Beast felt like two feature lengths films and a short mushed together in to one movie (in a way, this was Bonello’s
She Hate Me). The film follows two lovers that cross paths with one another through different time periods. Bertrand Bonello takes the audience back & forth between the early 1900s and a post-Covid mask-wearing dystopian future with a pitstop in to modern day California.
The California section of the film, which owes a lot to Maya Deren’s
Meshes and David Lynch’s
Lost Highway, is the only interesting part of the movie but still not enough to stop me from checking my watch every 10-15 minutes (it should also be noted that this is Bertrand’s second feature in a row to borrow heavily from Maya Deren. Read my thoughts on
Zombi Child
here).
 |
| Meshes Of The Afternoon / The Beast |
| Meshes Of The Afternoon / The Beast |
|
| Meshes Of The Afternoon / The Beast |
I was resistant to compare this to David Lynch but after I re-watch I came to the realization that is has quite a few Lynch-esque moments...
I think Season Three, the Return… I mean, it was a real shock for me as a filmmaker and it has been very present in my mind since I saw it. Maybe the biggest influence of David Lynch on me is the possibility to be free - David Lynch, thecurb.com
 |
| Twin Peaks: Season 3 / The Beast |
there was a screening of the film in a Paris a few days ago, and someone told me that in one of Louis’ videos you can see David Lynch’s house in the background. I don’t know if that’s true, but maybe there’s a connection there - Bertrand Bonello, BFI
 |
| Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me / The Beast |
|
 |
Lost Highway / The Beast
|
 |
Inland Empire / The Beast
|
 |
Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me / The Beast
|
 |
Inland Empire / The Beast
|
The Beast vision board:
I watched two films before shooting. One was The Age Of Innocence by Scorsese. The other was When a Stranger Calls - Bertrand Bonello, Hammertonail.com
 |
The Age Of Innocence / The Beast
|
 |
When A Stranger Calls / The Beast
|
Earlier this year there was some press about
The Beast being rejected from the Cannes film festival and now that I’ve seen it I kind of understand why. Movies don’t need to have a complete thought, a "satisfying" ending, or a set of rules to follow but I think
The Beast would have benefited from a bit more structure. Somewhere within the 140+ minutes that is
The Beast is a 72 minute feature that could have possibly worked. I’ve made this criticism before and I’ll do it again here - this movie is the equivalent of “showing your work” on a math test without getting to an actual answer.
